Well, I made a disastrous first attempt at Shortbread Cookies last night.
I’ve been hurting pretty severely these last two weeks, and only sleeping about 4 hours a night, if that, so I’ve been prowling around trying to find things to distract me. When I hurt this bad, it’s hard for me to do any one thing for very long. I can’t concentrate to write, TV doesn’t hold my attention, and I can barely move, so gardening or anything physical is out. I did read several Dean Koontz novels and both of the books by Patrick Rothfuss, so that helped some. But I got the idea last night that I’d give shortbread cookies a shot.
For the record: I cannot bake! Now it’s not really something I worry about, but since I’m actually pretty good in the kitchen, it’s kind of embarrassing that I’m sooooooo bad at baking.
Chicken and dumplings, I rock. Thanksgiving turkey, people rave. Smoked bacon & chipotle bbq sauce on smoked tri-tip sandwiches, they line up around the block. Shortbread Cookies? The way mine turned out you could slap a coat of floor sealer on them and have a drink coaster that would last for eons.
I’m a “splash-of-this pinch-of-that” kind of guy when I cook. I like flavorful food, and so spices are my friends. I’ve got kind of an intuitive sense of how to season dishes and when something is fully cooked. Don’t know where it came from, and haven’t really tried to hone it, but it’s there nonetheless. If you want a great grilled steak, I’m your guy. Stir-fry? Look no further. Baked goods? Keep on walking.
A few years ago, well, maybe over a decade, my sister gave me a stand mixer. (My sister, btw, is an absolutely phenomenally amazing cook and baker. I’m just sayin’.) However, her attempt to nudge me into baking with a really good mixer, failed. The mixer looks cool on the counter, but in all these years I’ve never used it. Not a single time. I know, I know, what a waste; honestly, if you could see my face right now you’d see that I’m thoroughly ashamed! And so, faced with mind-numbing pain and a cloak of shame, I slid the mixer into a more prominent position on the counter and assembled my ingredients.
As a side note: I make really good chocolate chip cookies – I mean really, really good; and I don’t measure anything very carefully, but you can get away with that on chocolate chip cookies. At least I have.
But in true baking, you need to measure, and measure carefully. Paula Deen, I’ve been listening. So I got everything ready, which was actually only three ingredients, and I let the disaster begin.
First, my butter was too cold when I put it into the mixer. I missed the part where it was supposed to be room temperature. So, step one, which was supposed to “cream” my butter, resulted in the wire mixer thingy getting filled with two sticks worth of cold, unmixed, completely congealed butter. Refusing to admit that I could be that stupid, I carefully picked all the butter out of the wire mixer thingy, turned the mixer back on, and proved I really was that stupid since all the butter once again jumped inside that silly wire mixer thingy. (Wire Mixer Thingy: a hideously evil contraption that most people would identify as a whisk.) Since by that time it hurt too much to stand, I took a break and let the butter reach room temperature while I tried to do the same.
So, a long while later (it took me longer to “cool off” than it did for the butter to “warm up”), I finally got back to it, deciding I would just throw the sugar in there to help “cut” the butter into the much-sought-after creamy stage. And it kind of worked. (Just FYI, Rascal does NOT like the sound the mixer makes.)
So, according to the directions I had printed out, my next step was to take my concoction and add in flour, mixing it by hand with a wooden spoon. What? Why use the mixer for anything in the first place? I could have just nuked the butter and tossed in some sugar if I was gonna have to do the hardest part with my hand. (People with RA do not hold wooden spoons very well. And hand-mixing, forgetaboutit.)
So, after spending ages trying to scrape the “creamed” butter-sugar mixture off the satan-spawned wire mixer thingy, I added my flour. I learned that the cookies are called “shortbread” because you add the smallest amount of flour you can until you reach the desired texture. What I didn’t learn was what the “desired” texture really was. But I winged it, figuring the right texture was the one I reached when my hands hurt too much to continue stirring.
Next, the directions told me to divide the mixture between 3, 8-inch round cake pans. Um... Well, since I never bake anything you can’t really expect me to have 3, 8-inch cake pans, now can you? Or even anything resembling a cake pan, for that matter. I did find a ceramic dish I use to make broccoli-rice-cheese casserole. So, since it was good and deep, I just threw all the “dough” into there and pressed it down hard to flatten it out evenly.
The directions said 30 minutes at 325. I know my way around a stove, so that part was easy – or should have been. At the 30 minute mark my dough was still the color of raw flour and as goopy as soup. I left it, checked it again in 5 minutes, then 5 more, then 10 more, still goop. So, at the hour mark I said...well, my mom might read this so I’m not going to tell you what I said, but needless to say: I gave up.
Much to my delight, the goopy mixture began to harden as it cooled. Whoopee! But it just kept hardening...and hardening...and hardening – is there a mathematical symbol for hardening to infinity?
Once I managed to chip them out of the dish (using a chisel and hammer), and broke them into pieces using an even larger hammer, my shortbread cookie (pieces) weren’t that bad. Well, as long as you soaked them for half-an-hour in some coffee.
Shrug. Did I mention I’m not so hot at the whole baking thing? I did? Good, because that should pretty much sum up the experience.